?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry Share Flag
4 Things Sword and Sorcery Needs to Improve to Become More Popular
initials
a_r_williams
When I was submitting to e-zines and magazines, one thing I noticed was that even though fantasy had a lot more opportunities to publish short stories online than other genres—sword and sorcery was rarely wanted. Some, said that they accepted sword and sorcery, but on reading their issues it became clear that sword and sorcery was not really something they published. Epic fantasy, for the most part, is the king of the fantasy genre. Sword and Sorcery is the red-headed step child.
What makes sword and sorcery viewed in such a manner? Why is it often seen as the lesser of the fantasy sub genres?
I think there are a few reasons why sword and sorcery has progressed into the role it has in fantasy and maybe by realizing this, and adjusting to reader desires, it will be become more prevalent in the future. Here are some thoughts why sword and sorcery may be sidekick rather than the hero when it comes to fantasy fiction.

1. Length - Robert E. Howard the inventor of Conan and the father of Sword and Sorcery published his works in the pulp era. Magazines were plentiful and short stories were a major source of entertainment. Sword and sorcery stories were born during this period. Their length and style of plot based fiction was perfect for shorter works. Readers didn’t mind reading short stories. Howard only wrote one Conan story that was of novel length. That fact never hindered the stories that were published or peoples interest in reading Howard’s work.

Today, readers want to invest in multi-book worlds. They want massive, sprawling trilogies, or ten book long series. They don’t want shorter works because they end too soon, leaving them to hunt for something else to read.

Sword and sorcery is a plot driven story type focused usually on a single character’s personal problems. It just doesn’t have a need to span multiple volumes.

Solution: Write single volume tales featuring one particular character. Character X and the Murdering Mummy … Character X and the Badlands Pirate … Character X and the Slithering Sorcerer.

2. Clones - Howard and Tolkien are both well known and successful fantasy writers. Success breeds mimicry. But in the case of sword and sorcery versus epic fantasy, the things people copied from the two masters are completely different.
From Tolkien, people copied his world and the types of people that populated it, the epic size of the tale, and the moral certainty of good versus evil.

From Howard, they tried to capture his writing style.
So, in the case of Tolkien you end up with: Elves, Dwarves, and Orcs, trilogies or longer novelizations, good versus evil, Halflings, the artifact hunt/quest, and the reborn dark lord from 1,000 years in the past.

Some of those things are what people enjoy the most—long stories, epic sized tales, good heroes battling evil.
But, part of what weakened sword and sorcery as a genre is what writers inspired by Howard tried to emulate—his voice. Voice can be one of the most important things a writer brings to their work, but when they try to copy someone else’s voice—it just doesn’t ring true. It comes off sounding fake or false (and they never do it as good as the original).

Solution: Simple. Write using your own voice.

3. Hack-and-Slash (and the movie experience) - This may be one of the greatest obstacles to sword and sorcery’s success. Combat scenes are difficult to do well, even in plot focused works.
But even in plot focused works—the reader needs something more than hack and slash—they still need story and characterization.

I think part of the reason the last Conan movie failed—is because they thought all they needed to show was Conan in an action scene to act as all the characterization they needed.
Action scene, followed by another action scene, followed by another action scene, followed by cheesy banter, followed by, yep, you guessed it—another action scene.

The reason so many sword and sorcery movies failed—is because they were made as only plot scene with nothing but action and no character development.

Solution: Give readers a character that has emotional depth. Conan, had depth. He wasn’t just a stupid hack and slash barbarian.

4. Grey characters and anti-heroes — Most readers want to read about the noble knight in shining armor—the unvarnished hero. They want to read about good versus evil. Sword and sorcery doesn’t necessarily provide that. It has shades of grey and darkness, it’s the antithesis of epic fantasy.

George R.R. Martin’s “A Song of Ice and Fire” makes use of grey characters. But Martin, doesn’t just stop at making a character grey. He shows their good side. He shows their bad side. He shows how they struggle between the two and how people interact with that character based on the facet that other’s have seen. Jaime Lannister isn’t just a kingslayer—he’s a hero in his own right. The Hound isn’t just some non-feeling, badass thug. He has fears and emotions.

Solution: Make your characters grey or an anti-hero if desired. But, also show the other aspects of their personality, make them feel so that they can bring something to the reader more than just another hack-and-slash adventure.

To wrap it up, I would like to hear from you. What are some of the things you think sword and sorcery needs to improve upon to become more popular in the genre where epic fantasy reigns supreme?


  • 1
I think it would benefit from more variety. Look at the sword & soul variation, which is African-inspired sword & sorcery. You can do that with any culture.

Look in my Serial Poetry page, and you'll see Kande's Quest. I saw someone say that nobody ever based Always Chaotic Evil races on white people, so I just had to write that -- and it was a perfect fit for sword & soul. A grand quest, magic and mayhem, and evil demons. :D

Variety is always good. It's also helps to mix a little bit of the old with the new. You won't necessarily satisfy all of the old diehards, but you may bring some of them along for the ride. Thanks for commenting!

Edited at 2019-06-19 07:27 pm (UTC)

I took a look at your poem. It was an interesting story. Have you thought of expanding it? Maybe into more short stories? Or longer work?

I have written short stories and a few longer works in the past. Right now, what sells best is poetry via crowdfunding. Would you believe, the most popular series now exceed novel length? I oopsed some books again. :D

Currently the favorite is Polychrome Heroics, a superhero fantasy series that subdivides into many threads about different people and places. But I also have a bunch of other fantasy series, a little science fiction, a little horror, and one this-world lesbian romance.

The Poetry Fishbowl runs on the first Tuesday of each month. There's also a Creative Jam mid-month that I usually participate in. People give me prompts based on the theme, and I write about whatever they request. So if anyone wants to see more of Kande, all the have to do is ask. Next up will be July 2 with a theme of "Respect Is a Need." It'll show on my LJ if you watch that.

Cool! Sounds like you've been keeping busy.

Very busy. The throughput on crowdfunding is astronomically higher than for conventional publishing, and it's a great deal more profitable too. People tell me what they want, I write it, they buy most of it. Everybody wins.

  • 1